Mapping blood flow in the brain of athletes using an advanced form of ultrasound may make it easier to more accurately recognise concussions, according to a study presented at the American Academy of Neurology’s 68th Annual Meeting (15–21 April, Vancouver, Canada).
“There is growing evidence that concussions can change the blood flow in the brain,” said study author Robert Hamilton, co-founder of Neural Analytics in Los Angeles, USA. “While such changes may be detected with MRI, we believe there may be a less expensive and portable way to measure these changes with a transcranial Doppler (TCD) device.”
Transcranial Doppler uses ultrasound to map blood flow activity in the brain. Traditionally, it has measured variables like the speed and variability (pulse) of blood flowing through the arteries. But those measurements have not been enough to accurately detect concussion.
For this study, researchers used an advanced version of transcranial Doppler ultrasound to get a more complete picture of just how the blood moves through the middle cerebral artery, one of the three major arteries in the brain.
Researchers compared a group of 66 high school athletes in contact sports who had been recently diagnosed with a concussion to a control group of 169 high school student athletes from both contact and non-contact sports. Examples of collision sports included in the study were American football, soccer, basketball, hockey, water polo and lacrosse. The non-contact sports included were cheerleading, cross country, cycling, tennis and track. Both the control and concussion groups were approximately 30% female.
Each of the concussed athletes had their brain blood flow measured with the advanced ultrasound headset within an average of six days after the injury. They were also given a general concussion evaluation and had their blood pressure checked.
The study found that the advanced version of transcranial Doppler ultrasound was able to differentiate between healthy and concussed athletes 83% of the time. This is in contrast to traditional transcranial Doppler ultrasound measurements like change in cerebral blood flow reactivity which differentiated between the two 60% of the time, average blood flow speed which differentiated 55% of the time and blood flow resistance which differentiated 53% of the time.
“This research suggests that this advanced form of ultrasound may provide a more accurate diagnosis of concussion,” said Hamilton. “While more research is needed, the hope is such a tool could one day be used on the sidelines to help determine more quickly whether an athlete needs further testing.”
“This important work provides insight into a tool that may yet prove useful in the recognition and management of concussion,” said Jeffrey Kutcher, with the The Sports Neurology Clinic in Brighton, USA. “The potential of having an accessible technology that detects a physiological change following brain trauma is very exciting. However, what these detected blood flow changes mean to a patient’s clinical care is still unclear.”
“This is an important area of research. Testing of the transcranial Doppler technique at the sideline at the time of injury will be an important next step to determine its ultimate utility,” said Randolph S Marshall, with Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center in New York, USA.
The study was supported by the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation.